New users, SK gov mode ..... READ!!

[georgi UK]

=] hi, to use the SK gov mode means that certain prerequisites are met and understood, initially the SK unit needs a phase sensor fitted as outlined here =

https://www.helifreak.com/showthread.php?t=296946

from here the SK gov wizz is used to setup the handset =

https://www.helifreak.com/showthread.php?t=358016



to understand what is required at spool up follow the above diagram, on start up the ESC is in control (black) as we approach 1/4 stick the SK is looking for it's cue to takeover / engage with RPM1 (red, normal)

if this is rushed the gov cannot lock in properly and will produce poor RPM performance, the method needed is to open the throttle smoothly to half stick (zero pitch) and hold it there momentarily, the RPM's will overshoot and return to the RPM1 setting, there is a noticeable "dip" as this happens.

idle up 1 / 2 are instantaneous when the gov is engaged, hope this helps??!

[Jamesppp]

Georgie,
Is I recommended to try this with a Kontronik Heli Jive?
My understanding is the Heli Jive has a non adjustable 2 second interval from startup to handover
I'm not going to try this but would love to know if these 2 components can work together
After a successful first problem free "flight" yesterday I'll happily use the Jive internal gov for now
However, as my collection of SK controlled helis grows I do want to experience the Sk gov.
I may have to chose a diff brand ESC to do so????

[georgi UK]

=] James hi, it uses a unique timing protocol external gov mode, they worked closely with Mikado / Mr. Mel to perfect this.

I would think the SK needs a firmware to support this, as the v-bar did....

[Seasick78]

Does any of this matter if not using an electric model? Considering trying out an SK540 on a Whiplash gasser. Are there any special governor issues to be mindful of for that application? I will be using a stator gator for rpm pickup with a Zenoah engine.

- Josh

[desertstalker]

Originally Posted by Seasick78

Does any of this matter if not using an electric model? Considering trying out an SK540 on a Whiplash gasser. Are there any special governor issues to be mindful of for that application? I will be using a stator gator for rpm pickup with a Zenoah engine.

- Josh

Dont know how much the SK gov will like gassers, it does not have as many tune-able parameters as the VBar does for example, AFAIK the throttle on them is quite non-linear (compared to nitro) so the SK may have trouble there.

[Seasick78]

I've had no problem with the gov on my cgy750 other than a slight overspeed which I just haven't dialed down yet.

Are you saying you're just not sure, or you think it will be a problem?

An rpm sensor sends a standard signal regardless of the engine and the gov should function to regulate the rpm based on that signal and based on the overall rpm as long as the gear ratio is properly identified, no?

If its going to be a problem I won't even open the box and I'll just return it while I still can.

[Seasick78]

I called and spoke with Brandon and he said there should be know issue. The functionality of the gov for nitro vs gasoline engine should be any different.

=)

Josh

[Seasick78]

So I installed the unit yesterday. Hookup was a breeze. Setup was a breeze. Running the model, on the other hand... Not so much.

Everything (all servos and the gyro itself) got too hot to even touch. Flashing red light also. Not sure what's up with the governor, but the throttle was revving up and down constantly (never happens on my cgy750).

I removed the whole thing from my model to inspect and as I picked it up in my hand I could hear something shaking around in there. Then, one of the machine screws fell out of the unit and right into my hand. Maybe its a nut on the inside where the screw goes in???

I don't know, but I only got two flights on this thing. Both were terrible. Will be calling Skookum as soon as they open to send this thing back in for warranty.

Bolted up my CGY750 again, ran some new settings and it's working quite well now. I only bought the 540 because of how laborious it has been to adjust the 750.

I hope I just got a defective unit or something. I'd love to try it again.

- Josh

[georgi UK]

=] Josh, there is no nut? request SK x-ship another unit to you....

[spikestabber]

To quickly add:

All Castle ICE controllers:

You will need a HobbyWing digital phase sensor and Beta firmware 4.01.

Set the ESC to Airplane mode with fixed endpoints, and a custom response time of 10.

It works on Skookum pretty much identical to the VBar setups that get talked about a lot more.

I wont get into Gear ratios, I'm sure Georgi can repost his easy to understand info from other threads.

The ESC will not have a soft start, but the SK ramp quickly takes over after the initial (but short) burst of ESC power when you open your throttle. The burst seems to depend on how long your motor takes to start and the SK-720 getting an RPM signal out of it.

I have not found any flaws with this setup so far on my 450.

[Seasick78]

I've sent an email with no response.

[Seasick78]

Still no answer on the phone and no response to my email....

[Seasick78]

Holiday in Canada... Hopefully get a response tomorrow.

[georgi UK]

=] +1

[InvertedCNC]

Ok, I'm obviously in the minority here as a nitro user...but this gov is completely backassward for nitro. Is it too much to ask for a nitro gov update that is up to industry standards? ...one that is flight mode switchable via aux channel and none of this throttle curve junk? Patiently waited through faulty usb ports..cracked cases..low vib tolerances..promised gps. please can we nitro guys at least get a serviceable gov? please.....

[Laos_pilot]

I have some question here.
At my rc club there is some heli using vbar gov, and i read that somebody here tell me that sk gov is awesome like the vbar one.
But i setup it to my 450, i cant feel happy with it, mine is not good as my friend heli, gov is too low. But if i increase the gov gain, tail is wag, yes i stick at small heli already. But why my heli is too bad? We using the same Align esc, same motor and same battery or sensor. So i think SK gov is not good like Vbar.
When I increase the gov gain, from 32 to 44, my heli is better, like the vbar but tail wag alot. Tried to low the rate gain to 40 or 50 but cant help. I think may be the throtle response rate of Align esc is not compatible with SK gov throtle command? Any ideas?
Sorry about my bad english, if you see my word is impolite, pls forgive me

[Geffect]

Yes the SK540 gov. is awesome..
I had a similar problem when i turned the gov on, and it it was a slight binding with one of the tail grip links.. Resized and tail is perfect..

You maybe running the same heli and equipment but have you checked the mechanical setup of the heli? Checked for binding in the tail mechanics, sloppy links, slop in servo?
Mechanical issues will get highlighted more with the rapid, subtle rpm changes that the gov. does...
If you are running plastic tail blades change to C/F as plastic ones will flex too much causing the tail gyro to wag with the rpm changes..

[ckindt]

Hi. Please pardon my ignorance, but why is the skookum governor mode recommended over the CC Ice governor?

Currently, I use the SK720 without using its governor mode. I use the fixed speed governor in my CC Ice.
It seems to work ok, but as most heli pilots out there I'd like to take advantage of using the best set up as possible plus I love to tweak with things just for the thrill of learning something new.

[georgi UK]

=] hi, the SK is gov is proactive which means it knows what's coming in advance and adjusts accordingly, the CC is reactive so it needs to see things when its too late before it can respond.

in addition the SK uses "pitch management" to control the headspeed when bogging is detected, so yes its superior and has bits to tweak!!

[Laos_pilot]

hi all you guy
I was wonder is it tail mechanic fail or not? And I try to use the disable gov in tail bank 2.
Everytime I switch to tail bank 2, gov is deactived, and my tail is rock solid. So I start to think that is not a tail mechanic problem.
I am using the plastic tail blade now, KBDD, my be I switch to RJX carbon one. And still think that Align ESC's throttle response is not quick enought to run governor smoothly, but hard to find someone who sale Hobbywing in Laos. Do you think like me??